NOT ON SUBSTACK. Go to THERACKET.NEWS to subscribe.

NOT ON SUBSTACK. Go to THERACKET.NEWS to subscribe.

Share this post

NOT ON SUBSTACK. Go to THERACKET.NEWS to subscribe.
NOT ON SUBSTACK. Go to THERACKET.NEWS to subscribe.
My Jimmy Buffett conspiracy theory

My Jimmy Buffett conspiracy theory

For entertainment purposes only

Jonathan M. Katz's avatar
Jonathan M. Katz
Sep 05, 2023
∙ Paid
19

Share this post

NOT ON SUBSTACK. Go to THERACKET.NEWS to subscribe.
NOT ON SUBSTACK. Go to THERACKET.NEWS to subscribe.
My Jimmy Buffett conspiracy theory
12
2
Share

Have you ever found yourself in one of those ice-breaker games where the question is: What’s a conspiracy theory you believe in? I have an answer that I’m always afraid to give, for three reasons: it’s embarrassing, I’ve never been able to prove it, and also I can’t keep from wondering if it might be true. So I guess I’ll make a newsletter out of it.

It came out of a chance—and fairly weird!—encounter I had with Jimmy Buffett, over thirteen years ago. As you probably know, Buffett died this past Friday at his home in Sag Harbor, Long Island.1 I always liked his music fine, though I’ve never been what you’d call a big fan, much less a “Parrot Head,” as his most zealous admirers call themselves. But I did achieve what one fan site called the “#1 Sign You’re a Parrot Head”: I escaped to “the islands,” moving from Washington to the island of Hispaniola in my mid-twenties, where I ended up spending five and a half years as an Associated Press correspondent.

The Racket is a reader-supported publication. If you like it, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

It was there on Hispaniola—specifically in Haiti—that I met Mr. Margaritaville:

(I’m the one in the Yankee cap.)

Here’s the story. It was early March 2010, a little under three months after the catastrophic earthquake that wrecked Port-au-Prince and other cities in southern Haiti. The capital was still in utter ruins: hundreds of thousands were dead, something on the order of a million people made homeless. I was technically one of the latter group, though far better off than most; in those days I was sleeping in a very nice camping tent, working in the makeshift bureau my off-island colleagues had set up, and moving around with little trouble—on motorcycles, mostly, since they could work their way around the rubble.2

On this particular March afternoon, I found myself at the famous Hotel Oloffson. The

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Jonathan M. Katz
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share